What I want to show here are the orbitals because I think they look kind of cool. What you see are the two highest occupied orbitals (n, π) and the lowest unoccupied orbital (π*). The two important excitations are just between these orbitals leading to the ππ* and nπ* states respectively.
Related to the proton transfer it can be seen that the π* LUMO has more density on the N which increases its basicity to help it catch the proton.
Something else that is interesting is that a non-bonding orbital (coming from MO theory) really looks a lot like the free electron pair you would talk about in VB theory. I was arguing with an analytical chemistry professor once that he should not interchange the terms non-bonding orbital and free electron pair because they come from different approaches. Now I see that he was right but I did not believe him then because he was from analytical chemistry.
Enol (ground state) | Keto (ππ* state) | |
π* | ||
π | ||
n |
2 comments:
Hello,
I have recently read a paper from Marcus Elsner et al. in PNAS (http://www.pnas.org/content/105/50/19672.abstract?sid=b2adfe84-c3f9-438e-806f-0b22f7f0afea) where they claim that their DFTB method can reproduce DFT(w. B3-LYP) calculations. They applied this to a small part of a protein. Have you done any other calculation to test the DFTB method for the keto/Enol stuff?
How did you do the dynamics? Newton? Langevin? Wavefunction propagation?
It's not that easy to believe in results when you not know about the used methods :)
Greetings
Till
actually this is not really related to my group's paper where they used TDDFT/B3LYP with Newtonian and wave packet dynamics (http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chemphys.2007.10.021)
we have some good experience with DFTB for modelling solvation in the ground state including hydrogen bonds (that is not really my topic though). here the topic was time-dependent DFTB for excited states and that is a whole different question. TD-DFTB is amazing because it's so fast. but since already TDDFT causes problems in many cases it is even more of an issue here
Post a Comment